I currently use *ScribeMe* ( *Be my eyes *) and *Be My Eyes*, both of which also work on Meta glasses. Everyone is recommending that I buy these glasses, but the truth is, I donβt have the luxury of just trying them out on a whim.
Because of that, I really need to hear from blind users who have actually tested them in the real world:
* **Are they genuinely useful, and do they provide more independence than just running the apps on my phone?**
* **Will I actually be able to use them outside in the street, or in unfamiliar places I visit?**
* **When Iβm around people, will the glasses describe who they are and what they are doing without me having to ask?**
* **What about audio description for movies?**
as a person with some Hearing loss, will it be valyable for me?
I would love to hear your honest feedback and experiences as fellow blind individuals who have used these glasses on the ground.
Comments
meta glasses
**
* **Will I actually be able to use them outside in the street, or in unfamiliar places I visit?** Yes, you could prompt meta AI to describe your surroundings. I do this a lot when I'm out and about.
* **When Iβm around people, will the glasses describe who they are and what they are doing without me having to ask?** No. You have to prompt meta AI with "Hey meta" each time. There is a thing called follow up mode, where it'll listen for a few extra seconds after it answers you in case you want to ask something else.
* **What about audio description for movies?** It doesn't offer audio description for movies. Even the live AI wouldn't really be sufficient for that.
as a person with some Hearing loss, will it be valyable for me? I don't have enough experience with this to answer adequately.
be my eyes or scribe me?
did you try to use it with Be my eyes? or scribe me? am asking because i saw some articales about using it with Scribe me to see movies etc.
just asking.
Thanks
be my eyes
I have used it with my be eyes, but I haven't used it for ScribeMe.
what model should i chhose?
am trying to decide which model should i choose, and am reading some posts, but can not decide,
if you know, can you tell me the difference? just the over all looking? or there are differences in speakrs cameras etc?
models
I'm not sure the differences in the models. Maybe someone else can chime in, sorry about that.
My thoughts
First and foremost, go with the Sports model. They are wrap-around style sunglasses, which means they should be more comfortable and fit better on your face. I do believe they also have an action button, similar to the action button on the latest iPhone models. The ones I would recommend would be the Oakley vanguard, I believe that is the Sports model.
As for independence, there is a lot of functionality you can get out of the Meta Smart glasses. While there are many features you can do on your iPhone by itself, the biggest trick to using your smart phone, is aiming. With smart glasses, you don't really have to aim, just keep your face pointed in the direction of the thing you want to scan/read/describe. Meta smart glasses also have a Live AI mode, although it is a battery sync, the AI will run in real time, allowing you to continuously ask questions without having to repeatedly say the phrase, "hey Meta," allowing you to transition from one query to the next smoothly. What this means is instead of trying to identify or describe things in an environment, such as a clothing store for example, instead of having to say, "hey Meta, what is this?", And, "hey Meta, what color is this," and, "hey Meta, what does this say?", You can simply go from query to query without saying the catchphrase. It's really for convenience, but trust me it's handy.
Meta Smart glasses are also good for helping you create calendar events, and reminders. The smart glasses can be reading a document, such as a letter you got in the mail. If there is a phone number in that document, you can interrupt the smart glasses and say something like, "hey Meta, call that number," and Meta will dial the number that's in the document. Of course it's handy for reading things like street signs and shop signs. Business hours printed on a door or window. Describing the color, make, and model of a vehicle, and even telling you if it has any markings on it describing it as a rideshare vehicle, such as Uber.
Meta can theoretically even read handwritten notes, although I have never tested this myself.
Meta smart glasses are really good for kitchen use. You can ask Meta to read food packages, including nutrition facts and expiration dates. If you're looking for cooking instructions, you can ask it just for that, and it will scan the package and only give you the cooking instructions and nothing else. You can also ask the AI questions like, "hey Meta, how long would I cook two boneless, skinless chicken breast in a conventional oven?", And Meta would give you precise instructions on this.
So, to summarize, Meta Smart glasses can be very beneficial, and give you some semblance of independence, but it will not replace your cane, or a guide dog.
hth. π
Brian
Hi Brian,
Thank you for all the clarifications, but I have a few simple inquiries.
As someone who uses hearing aids in my daily life, how will I hear the glasses? Will the speakers be next to the ear, or inside the ear?
Regarding the model you suggested, can I wear it with a formal suit at an event, for example? Or is it restricted to sportswear or casual clothing only?
I noticed that some apps have started integrating with platforms like Be My Eyes. Will this app add anything new to Meta Assistant, or is it an alternative? What are the benefits of linking the glasses to these apps?
Of course, it won't replace a guide dog or a white cane, but it is a powerful assistive tool.
Thank you so much for your care and attention.
A couple of thoughts
Firstly, I'm not sure what country you are in but just make sure that the features you are after are available to you. I'm in the UK and get most of the important stuff, but the release notes are always peppered with "only in the US and Canada". I think Australia and the UK get most things, but not so sure beyond that.
Secondly, a note on integration. The glasses can do lots of stuff on their own. There is a Meta AI app you need to have running all the time on your phone, but from there you can connect to WhatsApp, Be My Eyes, Spotify and various other things. This allows you to say "hey meta, be my eyes" to connect directly to a volunteer, for example, or to start a WhatsApp call with someone and then give them access to your camera.
I'm a little confused by what the Live AI thing is. I I don't think it's available in the UK. I do get a follow-on thing so I can ask more questions without saying Hey Meta again. Maybe the difference is that it is taking photos all the time in the other mode?
For Be My Eyes specifically, I believe you can only call a volunteer - I'm not aware of anything like Be my AI, service directory etc working with the glasses.
There is another type of integration which is driven the other way around. This allows other app developers to use the glasses camera from their own apps using the Meta SDK. The only app like this I've tried is oorion. I believe the SDK still is in beta and can be a touch quirky but it's pretty good when it works.
For oorion, the way it works is I open the oorion app on my phone. At this point it connects to the glasses. I can then say "hey oorion" and issue it voice commands. Until I close the app, oorion is really the only thing in control of the glasses - I can't use Hey Meta until I quit the app. So I can say something like "hey oorion, find my cat" and it will take photos every few seconds and let me know if he can be seen. If so, you get a beep indicating where he is or it will say something like "I can see a cat sitting on a chair in front of you". It's impressive but a little hit and miss - sometimes it gets left and right muddled up and sometimes it seems to be pointing me somewhere and I still can't find the thing. This is the same if you are just using this app directly from the phone so it's nothing to do with the glasses. Shaun from Double Tap uses oorion and the glasses when out for a walk - he says something like "keep watching out for any obstacles on the pavement" or something and it will keep telling him if the coast is clear or not. (Note: he does not make out that this can be 100% relied on and it is definitely, definitely not a replacement for a cane/dog or good O&M skills but I think it gives him a little extra info he can then decide whether to make use of or not.
One other thing I noticed in oorion - it has a mode where it will read the text around you which is pretty good. But it does make a point of saying that the glasses camera is only so good for text and you might sometimes be better off using your phone, but it doesn't seem too bad to me.
Depending on your budget, the Meta glasses (ie not Ray-bans) might be worth a look. They are quite new and by far and away the cheapest. I think they might also have the action button and seem to be pretty comparable to the others. On Double Tap they were saying that the microphone had some initial (very bad) problems but that they might be fixed now so looks like a software thing.
Finally - in terms of the speakers. You wear them like normal glasses. The speakers are in the arms and fire into your ears. They do not sit inside the ears. I don't use hearing aids so can't comment on how well the two things work together.
mr grieves
Thanks so much for all the info.
an great that orion will be fully integrated.
i was thinking also about how can we replace the battery? but i read that it is not replacable,
but what you are saying is very promising.
wish i can have a chance to try before purchasing.
I contacted a big store here, and wish they will allow me to test features and see if it will help me or not.
THanks again for your help
Try before you buy
I'm only speaking about what's available in the UK so this might be different depending on where you live.
Some opticians here sell the Meta glasses so might well be able to give a demo. Alternatively, there may be some blindness/low vision services near you that might be able to do it.
I know if I buy something online here I am entitled to send it back for a refund within a certain number of days if I don't get on with it, so that might also be an option. Companies like Amazon tend to make it quite easy to do this.
will try
am waiting a friend of mine who has a store for electronics, if he will allow me testing the glasses. and see
THanks
mu thoughts
a staff at my group home, brought their Meta Ray band glasses in, and she offered everybody them, to try. . she let me try them out, and onistly, in my humble opinion, they are a waist of money. your phone does all they do, for cheeper and better. I was planning to purchase the Vangard ocleys, , but at that time, they were out of my price range.
The phone can do stuff, but you need a hand
The subject line says it all. If I were looking to buy a pair of smart glasses, though, I would wait for the soon to be available Echo Vision glass from Agiga. Better hard and soft ware, and made specifically to do more for blind people. I alredy have a pair of Ray-Ban Meta glasses, and they work OK, but the Echo Visions have been preordered, and will probably fit my needs better. But whichever you choose, they will leave both hands free as opposed to always pointing your phone at what you want information about.
Features might be unavailable in your region
Careful Ramy, features might be an issue. I am from the Middle East, and as far as I can tell features other regions enjoy are not available for my region.
Wait couple of months.
Hello, my recommendation is that you wait until this fall for the Android XR glasses to come out.
There are only a few months left. android XR will offer much more than what the other smart glasses can do today and what the promises of other glasses offer. If we pay close attention, Agiga Echovision offers only a few functionalities that you can count on the fingers of one hand, and to make it a little more decent, use the Google Gemini Business Enterprise with its own language foundation managed by Agiga team. The Android XR glasses will do many more tasks and will have a complete integration with your phone. Also here it should be noted that it depends on what operating system you use, but in this case with Android devices they will basically be wonderful.
the specialized labs department of Google DeepMind is also working on accessibility for people with visual impairments on its project Astra.
I will wait for these Google android XR glasses, although I have always been a fan of the Meta glasses. I hope this cell Waiting makes sense, as the upcoming Android XR glasses promise far tighter phone integration and vastly superior real-time multimodal capabilities through Project Astra. DeepMindβs focus on visual assistance could make them a much more capable, practical choice over existing options.
Meta glasses with hearing aids
HI Ramy.
I've not had a chance to tcheck out the newer Oakley glasses or the adventurer ones from Meta, it's a financial thing, but I can tell you the Ray-Banns do not work so well directly with hearing aids. That said, even with my significant hearing loss, I'm able to use the first generation Ray-Banns in quiet settings. The speakers are very near my hearing aids, and so I am able to understand the speech output. My understanding is that the Oakley version of the glasses has louder output from the speakers though, so you may have more success with those. You are not able to reliably route audio to your hearing aids from these glasses. I'm unsure whether this remains the case with the Adventurer model. The Echovision glasses pair with my hearing aids and do deliver speech output directly to my hearing aids. However, like others have said, I have no idea what features are or aren't available in Egypt. Good luck!
with Hearing aids
THanks so much for this info.
sure i will keep in mind.
Regarding availability, I think if i will purchase it, i will use with Scribe me or be my eyes, they are working in egypt
Android Glasses
Very promissing,
let's see what they can offer for us
THanks for the suggestion
Jst so everony knows regarding the meta glasses
I have not tried this yet but you can now get walking directions to where ever you wanna go if you're into hands free use like me. I'm only speaking as I'm in the US here and hopefully people of whom are in the US and I do believe Canada can chime in on this feature if they gotten it on their glasses and let me know how well it works. Man I do wish there was a program where we can trade in our old glasses for the newer models at least for a discount Lol.
A Few Thoughts
Yes, your phone can do most things the Meta glasses can do. You do need a free hand to hold your phone though. So it depends on if you need to be hands free or not. I use my Meta Ray Ban glasses quite a bit when I'm out and about. I'd say they are more of a convenience than a necessity in my case though, as I can have things read or described with apps on my phone too. I really like having the glasses though.
If getting the Ray Ban glasses, I'd definitely recommend the generation 2, as they have much better battery life than the generation 1 glasses. I don't have any experience with the other styles.
If you aren't in the US, definitely make sure the services and AI features you need are supported in your area.
One advantage of the Echo Vision glasses is that you can pair them with bluetooth devices like headphones, speakers, and some hearing aids. So if you have hearing aids that support bluetooth, you may be able to get audio directly through them instead of the Echo Vision glasses.
Re: Echo Vision
Just bear in mind that these are only available in the US (and maybe Canada). At the moment anyway..
IPhone Chest Mount as an alternative
I can't afford these yet - I just bought an iPhone, but I'm planning to get a thing that mounts the phone on my chest using a neck band. I think it's designed to have the phone facing you against your chest, but you can tilt it back to use it - at least I think that's how it'll work I haven't gotten it yet. From my understanding it's meant for things like youTube videos and such.
The angle probably won't be quite the same - obviously it's a bit lower down than glasses but it does deal with the problem of having to hold the phone. I'll be interested to see how well it works in practice.