I first saw EchoVision by Agiga at Vista Center Ignite Accessibility Entrepreneur Pitch Competition last month. It was hard for the AGI to hear me and for me to hear the descriptions and Be My Eyes in the noisy exhibit hall. Based on my interview with Blind Abilities, Huasongcm, CTO at Agiga reached out to Jeff and wanted to chat, where Jeff from Blind Abilities asked if I would like to be on it, where I agreed, but wanted to first examine it better at my roofttop farm that is quieter and allowed me more time with the glasses.
I was even more impressed than I was initially, as the scene descriptions via voice and Be My Eyes volunteer were great, but:
User Experience
- Agiga added follow-up to EchoVision, so it's possible to get more specific context/details about a scene, which was a feature request I had last month and and it's live in the prototype.
- Tap with one-finger on right-side towards front of glasses to get a scene description without asking, which is what i wish Meta Ray-Bans would do. There is a good amount of context/details to scene descriptions, which is made for blind people.
- It's responsive, latency is low, voice is somewhat natural human sounding, and speech rate can be increased. I tested the speech rate at 1.5x.
- I was able to call Be My Eyes and AIRA, where I got human description of a card no deets and scene.
- Holding down with 2-fingers on right side will cancel Be My Eyes or hang-up and return to main menu, where I heard I could use Google Lookout by saying: "Hello Agiga, Lookout", which goes into explore mode reading text and identifying objects real-time. It was able to identify different objects, including stairs, plant, read text on credit/debit card, and lottery ticket.
- I tried to have Lookout identify US currency, but it wanted to read the text on the bill instead. No worries though, a quick tap on the right-side did a quick scene description, where it described I was holding a $20.
- The form factor are wrap-around sun glasses, which blocks sun for those of us with peripheral eye-sight and light sensitivity, and is more secure as it partially wraps around the back of my head and doesn't slide down my nose like Meta Ray-Bans.
- I feel it has the features and functionality of Envision AI Glasses, but even better form factor than Meta Ray-Bans. I look forward to pre-ordering on October 11!
Feature Request
- I was trying to have it describe people, but it said it couldn't describe faces, but when Huasongc tested it at home with his wife, it could. Huasongc thought Be My Ai could, so we tried it and it can, so they'll work on people descriptions.
- I also tried something no AI could do, which was ask about next bus/train departures via Transit. Agiga is going to see if TransitApp has an API.
Comments
Believe it when I'll see it
Guess I'll believe it when I see it, so far, I've not been impressed with all these blindy company copycats trying to release something with flimsy hardware that does not work and half the time when they do, very poor! Also, having us have to pay more to get access to what we need. I've lost my trust with all this and I'll stick to my existing metas thank you very much. I'm sorry if I sound harsh but we've seen this time and time again with different glasses and tech products that claim to be made for us and yet do not work half the time. You do know that real world demo videos stuff can be edited as well yall realize that right? Not saying that the youtube channel in question is doing that but again, I'll believe it when I see it. Think it's time we take these companies for what they are and hold em accountable. Scam Lol. Na, just kidding but you know where I'm going with this. If a company claims that a product does what it's suppose to do but you find out that it don't do what it said on the box as well as it says then somethings gotta give here and that, my friends is false advertising. Something of which access companies love to do. I hope I'm wrong about these glasses but I ain't holding my breath.
Experiences
Every body is going to have their own perceptions and experiences, and even biases as to what they personally consider good tech over bad. I know I will never be able to, for example, convince Ash Rein how wonderful the Meta smart glasses are (for me). And I am not even trying to. They have obviously had a really unpleasant experience using them, and have decided the Meta glasses are not for them.
That is fair and understandable.
However, the Meta glasses have been amazing for me, and thus I will continue to use, and enjoy them. I get so much done with this device that I wonder how I ever lived without it. Again, my experiences have colored my perception and bias towards the Meta glasses in a positive way.
I won't list everything I have been able to do successfully with my Meta glasses because this rant would just go on, and on, and on... I will reiterate that I am happy with my pair and get quite a lot of independence out of using them. π€·
Thanks for reading. π
Meta Glasses
Just work. At least 70% of the time. That's much higher than what any of these blindness-specific companies have been able to demonstrate so far. They do that at half the price of any blindness-specific product of a similar nature that has been offered so far. 2 good enough reasons to convince me. I'll leave it at that.
Starting to feel a bit of FOMO about these Echovision glasses
Subject line mostly says it all. I've got the Ally Solos glasses, and, perhaps rather foolishly, got some Gen 2 Meta glasses because I was able to get them with extremely low monthly payments, and even though I wasn't keen on them the first time around, they were still able to do more than the Ally glasses are currently capable of, which, as Ash has pointed out, isn't exactly a ringing endorsement.
Now, I'm starting to think I should have skipped them both and held out for these Echovision glasses. I haven't heard as much about them as a lot of you seem to have, though, and delivery dates being delayed kind-a makes me think of Glideance. When the Echovision glasses are officially reality, I will certainly look forward to hearing demos, and if they somehow ever have a reasonable payment plan or something, maybe I'll add them to my collection, although I feel as though having 3 pairs of smart glasses would be more than a little ridiculous.
Apple Glasses probably would be ideal
I think you're absolutely right, Ash. Given that I've already spent way more than I ever wanted to on smart glasses, I'll probably try to resist the Echovision temptation and make do with what I already have until Apple releases smart glasses. Hopefully, they'll be much more affordable than that Applevision pro thing; I had 0 temptation to even think about that. I'm sure Google glasses will be seriiously awesome too, but since I'm exclusively in the apple ecosystem, waiting to find out what they come up with would probably be my best move.
Re: In the end, we will be using Apple glasses
This... I actually believe. Absolutely.
Convincing folks of stuff
I don't think anyone here's secretly meta's sales agents pretending as blind guys just to convince Ash Rain of the value of the Meta Glasses. I mean, noone of us is that important in the larger scheme of things. This feels more like Ash Rain trying to convince themselves and others (HARD) that what they've been saying is the only truth no matter what the majority of the user group feels, as if they're the only custodian of the absolute truth around here. Even that would've been tolerable if they would have not been bating specific individuals (in different ways) to respond to then. Well, personally, this is an interesting exercise though it does constitute a pointless loss of time...
@Ash Rain: "Itβs simply stating that I have seen multiple videos of the echo vision glasses working. A lot of of the worries that we have had have been directly addressed. The delays are very minimized, the overall descriptions are excellent, and from what people are saying, they are very comfortable." I imagine this is all based out of what Tom told Harry who told Shawn who probably told you and not from your own personal experience? How do you justify making such sweaping claims about a product that you haven't used yourself based purely on some youtube videos which could always have been editted? What gives you the authority to try to convince/misguide people about a product that you haven't even tried out? Yet, when people who used a product give their personal opinion, for you that's not objective. If that's not hypocritical, someone tell me what around here is? I have nothing against the Echo Vision Glasses and I really hope they will deliver; but I don't understand the logic wherein someone is absolutely blasting not only a product that's been around for about 2 years in the market and has been a possitive experience for most of the users (within the community), but also is on a crusade against anyone who is saying a good thing about it is able to convince themselves of the absolute efficacy of a product that they themselves have not used, much less is out in the market. Seems borderline suspicious if you ask me. "A lot of of the worries that we have had have been directly addressed". If I remember correctly, some of the worries that you have had about the Meta glasses included "It doesnβt describe things well. It gets a lot of things wrong. It isnβt reliable... It also doesnβt work in darker environments like nighttime... it is rudimentary at best... itβs a pair of heavy uncomfortable glasses... I donβt like people hearing anything that Iβm doing..." then something about "some illusion loop"... Given that you haven't used the Echo Vision glasses, on what objective basis are you trying to convince people that the glasses have been able to tackle all these problems? Much less, how have you convinced yourself? I remember you saying the meta glasses are a "cash grab" thing and that privacy is an ellusion with the device. What proof do you have that any other glass is any different?
Let me give another instance, around the same conversation, of you being absolutely hypocritical, logically flawed, biased and non-objective, all traits which you keep accusing other people of: in another conversation on the Meta Glasses themselves, I remember you chiding the folks who pre-ordered Glide, apparently because they did not listen to you and pre-ordered it and now it is getting delayed. And yet, you are right now convinced of a product that has had multiple delays already and about the timeline of which there is no clear indication.
And btw, on any sain day, I would vouch for a product that works 70% of the time over one that still exists in youtube videos, and anyone who does otherwise, like I said, seems borderline suspicious to me.
A final word: if anyone from Echovision Agiga is reading this, please understand that I have nothing against you guys. Like I said, I really hope that your glasses are able to deliver what has been promissed. I am following your product from the start, and am interested in them as I have been in any other product with the potential to solve the problems of the community. I am here just trying to address the biased way in which certain arguments have been put forth. So please don't take offence on that account.
Demonstration on Double tap
Agiga was yesterday present on the Double Tap show and demonstrated the Echo Vision smart glasses.
Don't know it's just me, but comparing it with earlier demos, for Ex on Carrys show last year, they sounded muchsmoother, the latency was much much lesser than before and the new Live-AI feature was also very impressive.
Feature Request
I hope sometime or later in the near future. be my eyes can have the live AI mode and then we can share the computer screen and let it d describe the pictures, video or read out the video ingame menu
Ash Rein
I am truly looking forward to this. Have fun! π
Looking forward to hear/read from you Ash
It delights me a lot, that you are finally receiveing your glasses.
From that what I saw, the delays weren't beeing without a reason, and if the impressions from the last Double Tap episode matches with reality, then it'll become very useful.
It'll have definitely it's own little issues, but so desasterous like another brand, which I don't want to name here, will it never be for sure!
I'm excited for your first impressions. Goodluck and hopefully glasses will arrive in Europe very soon!
Talking about California
Talking about California:
Last week I attended at CSUN event held in Anaheim California.
I took the time to visit AGIGA booth and I will try to be very positive in my comments much to everyone's surprise: the Glasses prototype AGIGA team are still showcasing is the pioneer edition.
in what world does anyone think AGIGA team going to produce the final version in just 3 months?
When they don't even have any proper prototype to show yet with the new improvements such as
new camera module, larger battery capacity and better quality material.
Sam is pretty awesome
Sam from The Blind Life has a ton of videos featuring tech reviews. Pretty cool channel to subscribe to. π
Excited like a chicken
Like the subject says, don't even know, that saying exists in real, but I'm very excited how the glasses will perform.
Does the performance in the field match with the presented results? We'll hopefully find out soon.
Re: Ash Rein
Disappointing that we likely now won't hear the promised demo, as it appears that Ash and their posts have left this siteπ
Am I missed something?
Something went wrong or what's the matter?
@bonerobot
The user known as Ash Rein deleted their account, and is no longer here on AppleVis.
Was looking forward
Was seriously looking forward for a real life demonstration of these glasses, especially with the proactive live AI and all.
I'm hopeful
That they will still do their demo, and just put it up on something like YouTube.
atheory
Like others, I was really looking forward to a demo of these glasses. I can't help wondering if the user in question ended up being disappointed in these glasses after receiving them. Of course, I have nothing what-so-ever to base that theory on, but it's a possibility to consider, I suppose.
@Missy Hoppe
It's as good a theory as any. π
availability?
when will these glasses be available? seems dodgy that a poor product was shipped, to be taken down whilst they work on things they've had more time before shipping even the first batch to get it right, something just seems off.
@Missy Hoppe
Ash Rein's disappearance has nothing to do with the glasses - it all played out in one of the other threads, possibly the Mac Neo thread. Anyway it was to do with cats although those posts will probably not be there any more. Anyway hopefully someone else will get theirs and we will get a nice review.
Regarding the delays, they were on Double Tap talking about this recently - my memory is a bit fuzzy these days but I think they had the opportunity to upgrade the battery significantly without affecting cost and decided it was worth switching at the last minute. Don't quote me though.
I think it's better to release a product late than broken. They may also have had one eye on what happened with the Envision Ally glasses and thought that this has to be right at launch. OK I always give these companies the benefit of the doubt but hopefully this will turn out well.
Re: Envision
I don't think Envision is looking too good right now. Let's hope the developers of these glasses won't go that same route.
Review
I have been a Pioneer user since December, but haven't had the time to put a review together. They are still actively taking feedback and I know several other users who pre-ordered have recently recieved theirs'. Hopefully someone will write one soon, though at this point, it wouldn't reflect the final version of the product.
Envision
Let's just say I'm not a happy camper at all. Now that Ally is available on the Meta glasses, or will be soon, I keep asking myself why I fell for the hype and bought the Ally Solos glasses. I'm actually selling mine to a sighted co-worker who only wants them for their ability to serve as headphones. I'm only charging him $150 for them because the build quality is questionabl e at best. I'm not a fan of the arms being detachable since getting them to connect properly after charging is very fiddly. At this point, I'm of the opinion that getting some money back is better than feeling as though I wasted $400. My smart glasses journey has been quite the fiasco, but I've got a pair of gen2 Meta Ray-bans now, and they meet my needs just fine. Ally scans documents with them, and it actually works a lot better than it did with the Ally Solos glasses. I'm still very interested in hearing demos of the Agiga glasses, but honestly have no plans to buy them at this time.
Agiga Team mention to release June or July
Hello! I had the chance to go at CSUN event held in Anaheim California.
.
I took the time to visit AGIGA booth and I will try to be very positive in my comments much to everyone's surprise: the Glasses prototype AGIGA team are still showcasing was the pioneer edition.
AGIGA team don't even have any proper prototype to show yet with the new improvements such as
new camera module, larger battery capacity and better quality material.
I don't think the final release glasses will be ready for June, Remember they promise to be ready in the 2nd quarter.
I also heard AGIGA team mention on the doble tap podcast to release in July which means already 3rd quarter
This almost Sounds like the situation with Glide
Remember how Glide was supposed to be released last September? I'm so thankful I was able to cancel my preorder for that. I have a friend who is getting one, so whenever he actually receives it, I'll look forward to checking it out. I have similar feelings about these glasses. I'll be excited to read people's thoughts and listen to demos, but at this point, I'm satisified with my Meta Ray-bans gen 2. Plus, I've already wasted way more money than I ever wanted to on smart glasses. Hoping for the sake of everyone looking forward to these that they really do end up getting released this year, and that they're everything Agiga promised. I think that was a major, major issue with the Ally Solos glasses. They were announced out of the clear blue, hyped up to sound beyond awesome, and then the actual product didn't live up to the hype, mostly, at least in my opinion, due to some highly questionable design choices. What I 've heard about the Agiga glasses makes me feel optamistic that at the very least, they're going to be a step up from the Ally Solos.