Keyboard shortcuts in Mavericks when using international keyboard layouts

By Cliff, 18 November, 2013

Forum
macOS and Mac Apps
Hi there, all great gurus of the Mac World! I've been facing a problem for a while, and I kind of hoped that this issue has been fixed in Mavericks, since Apple promised to look into it, but nothing has changed... So maybe you great knowledgeful people have thought out a solution for this. The problem is that many standard keyboard shortcuts rely on a english keyboard layout, both VO shortcuts and global shortcuts throughout the OS. Very often I stumble upon shortcuts that e.g. uses the left and right brackets, [ ]. On my norwegian keyboard layout, I'll have to press Option + 8 and 9 to reach those signs, and as you probably have gathered already, that isn't possible to do together with the VO keys, since the Option-key already is a part of the standard VO keys. So how do I solve this? I sent a mail to accessibility@apple.com a few days ago, about the Cmd+right and left arrows not longer working in Safari to go back and forth. The weird thing is that it works if you turn VO off, then press Cmd+left arrow to go back a page, and then turn VO back on again. They suggested that I use the old shortcut for doing this, which is Cmd+brackets, or was it VO+brackets? Can't remember right now, but the point is that I tried both then, and nothing worked, since the brackets on my norwegian keyboard can only be reached through pressing Option+8 or 9. I tried setting up a new global shortcut for it, to be Option + left to go back and Option + Right to go forth, but that also only worked when VO is turned off. Gets kind of frustrating to have to turn VO off and back on every time I want to go back to the previous page while browsing. The best solution I've found by now, is to set up a hotspot on the Back button in the toolbar of Safari, and then a new hotspot for the html-content. I also want to be able to skip between several open documents in TextEdit, without having to open the window-chooser each time I want to skip back and forth, and I suspect that the brackets again will come back to haunt me in the keyboard shortcut that is meant for doing just that. Also, some VO commands are made for an english keyboard layout, such as the command for resizing and moving objects. I think the key to the left of the 1-key is involved in doing this in the english keyboard. And it might be a ~if I remember correctly. Anyway, the key to the left of the 1-key on my keyboard is an ' (apostrophe), so obviously those commands is out of my reach too... If Apple could assign standard keyboard shortcuts to the physical key, in stead of the sign or symbol that is associated with the key in the software layout, this problem with different keyboard layouts and shortcuts would more or less be solved forever. But is there a clever workaround that someone of you can think of? Setting up a new global shortcut for going back and forth in Safari sure didn't work, if VO is running that is. And how would I go about switching from document 1 to document 2 in textedit without having to use the window-chooser? Og how can I switch between open Finder-windows, without the window-chooser? Thanks in advance for any good advice, and as always, sorry for the length of this post! Haha... Too much coffee again! Lol :)

Options

Comments

By Esther on Thursday, December 5, 2013 - 23:21

Hi Cliff,

I'm going to assume that you're running your Mac with a Norwegian localization, and that you're probably using a Norwegian input keyboard (one of three available), but that you might be switching to an English language input keyboard on occasion.  Your language localization, input language keyboard, and VoiceOver voice language are all different parts of your language setup.  Even though I switch input language keyboards and voices, I use a U.S. English localization on my account.  Some users create alternate user accounts for themselves in a different language localization (e.g. English and French), and actually switch between accounts.

First question: does Control-F4 work for you to switch between your TextEdit windows?  The Apple Knowledge Base document on OS X Keyboard shortcuts:

http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1343

lists Control-F4 as "Move focus to the active (or next) window" with Shift-Control-F4 as "Move focus to the previously active window".  I'd expect these Control+F-key shortcuts to work for all Macs, regardless of localization.

Secondly, it's not necessarily true that the Mac kyeboard shortcuts for your localization will be the same as for someone using an English localization.  I came across a Google search reference that mentioned that for one user of the Finnish keyboard, for example, the shortcut Command+< (where the last character is the "less than" symbol) worked to switch between windows of an application.  This was back in 2011, so I don't know whether this is still true. And by the way, I just checked all three of the Norwegian keyboards for the Mac (Norwegian, Norwegian Extended, and Norwegian Sami-PC), and on all of these keyboards the key to the left of the "1" key is reported as "<" (the less than symbol).  One of the first things you need to determine is whether the default keyboard shortcuts for your Mac are actually the same as the ones for someone with an English language localization.  To find out what the default shortcuts are for your Mac and its language localization, go to "System Preferences".  I'm not running Mavericks, but I've read that the "Language & Text" option where your localization is set has been reorganized as "Language & Region", where you set your preferred languages.  However, the place you really want to check is "Keyboard" under the "Keyboard Shortcuts" tab that is named "Shortcuts" under Mavericks.  This is where you can customize and change the keyboard shortcuts for various actions, but where you can also check what the default assignments are.  In the case of switching between TextEdit windows, I would navigate to the "Shortcuts Category" table and interact, then select "Keyboard & Text Input". VO-J to jump to the associated "Table of Shortcuts" and find "Move focus to next window". I'll hear the default keyboard shortcut for this announced as Command-accent, where "accent" is the grave accent on the key to the left of the "1" key in the numbers row on my Mac. Apparently, this was the way the Finnish user found out that the Command+< shortcut was the default shortcut for switching between application windows.  I don't know whether this is still true, or what you will find when you check the default keyboard shortcuts for Norwegian

Some problems (like whether Command+Right Arrow or Left Arrow) works for your browser, may be specific to your language localization.  (By that I mean there can be a bug in how this works only for your language.  A few years ago there was a bug in VoiceOver focus on iTunes syncing with the iPad Nano, such that in the German localization you couldn't read the playlists, podcasts, or contacts on the tabs when the device was connected.  The workaround was to force iTunes to run under an English localization when the user wanted to change selection of playlists, podcasts, etc. but to let him sync the device with iTunes launced in German, in the usual way until the problem got fixed.) If Command+Right or Left Arrow works for you when VoiceOver is disabled, then you can try first issuing the VoiceOver escape shortcut (VO-tab, or Control-Option tab) before pressing Command-Right or Left arrow. VO-tab instructs VoiceOver to ignore the next command.  An example where this was recently discussed on the mac-access list was the keyboard shortcut for starting a new audio recording in QuickTime.  The QuickTime file menu lists this shortcut as Command-Control-Option-N, but if you issue this with VoiceOver active you just hear a "boink" sound, because the shortcut conflicts with the VoiceOver shortcut for finding the next auto web spot. However, to avoid having to navigate to the File menu to start a new audio recording, VoiceOver users can press VO-tab followed by ommand-Control-Option-N. That trick might work for your Command-Left Arrow and Right Arrow web navigation, too. Another thing you could try is downloading the WebKit nightly build to use in place of Safari. WebKit is the engine that underlies Safari and a number of other browsers. The nightly builds incorporate changes that are being worked on since the last full Safari release, so sometimes they can contain fixes for ongoing problems. Becasue these are not official releases, they can also contain new bugs introduced as people work on things. My guess would be that your problem is language localization dependent, however, and not likely to be fixed by using the latest WebKit version in place of Safari.

For some keyboard shortcuts that are difficult to type, you can try using VO-h-h to bring up the VoiceOver commands menu.  This was the typical way that VoiceOver users with keyboards where it was difficult to type the "sort" command (VO-Shift-backslash on an English language keyboard) would access the "sort" function.  In other cases, such as toggling disclosure triangles, Apple chaged things so that pressing right or left arrow keys would work in place of the other keyboard shortcut.

It's actually not a good idea to tie keyboard shortcuts to the specific location of keys on the Apple Keyboards -- for one thing, it would mean that you wouldn't be able to use any other third party keyboard.  If you really want to remap your keys, I'm sure that you can do this with KeyRemap4MacBook.  You might even contact the developer with your questions.  That's how Eric Caron got the solution of mapping the VoiceOver keys to Caps Lock.

Finally, you're not likely to get a good discussion of international keyboard problems on the AppleVis site, since this type of discussion is more likely to occur on the mailing lists.  The only discussion of these issues I've seen on this site are the occasional complaints and questions.  I think there are a few proficient Mac VoiceOver users from Norway on the macvisionaries list -- John André of A-Pro Studio (a musician) always struck me as being a sensible fellow when he posted. And we've had other language related discussions on the mac-access list.

HTH.  Cheers,

Esther

 

 

Hi Esther, and thanks a lot for your thorough answer! :) Yes, localization is set to norwegian, so is also the keyboard input language, but I sometimes change both temporarily when planning to work more than a few minutes on english web-sites or in other situations where that obviously makes things easier. I've tried Ctrl-F4, and also Ctrl-Shift-F4, but they don't do nothing for me... I've also checked that list you linked to for standard OS shortcuts, and it doesn't seem like none of the keyboard shortcuts involving the Ctrl and Function keys are working for me in Mavericks... I've of course set the function keys to software use, because of the many VO shortcuts that rely on using them. The Ctrl- and also Ctrl-> commands has always worked for me to switch between windows, but only open Finder windows, never in apps. And to be clear, if VO didn't read that sign for you, that was Ctrl with less than and greater than signs... :) The less than and greater than symbols on my norwegian keyboard and in every other norwegian MacBook keyboards I've tried, is by the way located to the left of the Z key, so it's to the right of left shift. And to the left of the 1 key, is ' apostrophe. When I check the keyboard shortcuts in System Preferences, under Keyboard, and then move to next window, I can also see that the standard shortcut is, like the finish guy's, Ctrl- less than, but as mentioned above, this shortcut will only work for switching between open Finder windows. That's the way it behaved in MountainLion and it's the same now for Mavericks. So I've never had any luck with that command within different windows within an app... I tried your tip of ignoring the next VO command by hitting VO-Tab, before doing Cmd-left or right arrow in Safari, but unfortunately that didn't work either... Strange... Since turning VO off, then hitting Cmd-left arrow, and then turning VO back on again, will correctly take me to the previous page. So I absolutely got my hopes up for that tip, but no, didn't work. I've reported this issue to the accessibility team, and they can reproduce it, they told me, so I don't think this is a localization issue either, since they most likely are running their basic tests on an US english localization. That's when they told me to use the Cmd-brackets shortcuts instead, or was it VO-brackets? But of course, that's where it gets messy using a norwegian keyboard layout, where brackets isn't part of the standard repertoar of keys, but I'll have to hold down the Option keys while pressing 8 and 9 to reach it. I've also tried VO-H-H to bring up the VO commands help, to see if there's a possibility to switch between windows or go to previous page there, but there is no option in any of the categories there to do that, at least that I could find. But if there was, I could set up another shortcut for it in the VO utility, and the problem would be solved. So sadly I'm out of luck on that one too... ;/ Maybe I'll have to check out your tip about the Mac Visionaries list, I've never posted anything there, but that might be the right place to go if no-one is able to help me here on AppleVis! :) But I know John-Andre! Haha! A jolly fellow! He use to call me when he has Mac-trouble, since I've been a Mac-user for a longer time than he has! :) But you'll never know, he might sit on the answer to this keyboard layout conflict issue, that is causing me headaches! Haha! :) But thank you so much anyway, and I think maybe I'll check out KeyRemap, which you also mentioned... That might be the right way to go... But frankly, I think that should be unnecessary to do, when running Apples otherwise brilliant software! Thanks again, and take care! :)