This post is being fully written only with raw metal asahi linux fedora 42 with gnome, on firefox with orca. It's actually something usable now, thanks to the EU and Matt Campbell's incredible work.
I am writing this in the hope that it will be useful to someone... My mac is getting hot now like any average laptop, but yo it works!!! It's probably just way more unstable than any of the first developer beta of macos... I mean the accessibility. I am very very very very excited to test this out.
I don't mean anything by this but like the spell check actually works in this edit field! Just sayin.
No vim for me yet :( , at least with orca. But options are plenty...
Please buy any rim or scribe subscription you can!!!
Again thank you to everyone who is doing this incredible work for a niche within a niche within a niche.....
No, aside terminal, firefox, the installer itself :) , and alt f2, I literally haven't tried anything yet. Wonder how to get the classic menu of gnome classic, the like of mate? ...
See ya.
Please like and subscribe, but for the moment we can just subscribe so do that if you want.
No, I am not smiling like a kid currently. Not at all.
PS: this thing is actually very very faaast!
By TheBlindGuy07, 4 July, 2025
Forum
Assistive Technology
Comments
So I installed this yesterday and...
Gnome was pretty bad, but there were a few saving graces for it. The built in onedrive/google management for one. I couldn't really use the thing unless I switched to gnome classic and it wasn't much better. DNF groupinstall mate-desktop , and mate-appplications I believe from memory were the commands to install the thing but there was work to be done for it to show up on boot. I went through formatting because I couldn't stand eSpeak, but one day I will purchase vocalizer so it's a more viable platform for me, since eloquence isn't available on arm. Firefox and chromium were a joy to use compared to the Mac counterparts.
Does mate work with wayland?…
Does mate work with wayland? Would it share all the improvements made to gnome? Like so far it's just usable and it wasn't in October last year. Yes VO is really bad on the web. I don't want to break anything.
This wayland x11 thing is very confusing, I saw during update that it was getting some x-wayland things or something... Plus it's my first time to be outside debian/ubuntu roots for package management so I'm learning that at the same time. But we have something now! Thanks to the government, literally. If kde-connect can work on gnome I'll try it. And emacs+emacspeak. And libreoffice and Calibre. ... :) and I'll ask on those lists how best report accessibility bugs there.
No it does not work. I was wasting my time :D
From my research, Gnome is best with wayland for us, but it's possible the things I'm reading could be wrong, but I don't think so. Maybe building current Orca would have helped me, or maybe assistive technology checkbox is unchecked, but I don't know where that would be in Gnome. There's lots to love about it if you look past it though, for what works, IMO. We'll be using it soon enough if they work on it.
OMG Tables work well in…
OMG Tables work well in LibreOffice Writer as well as formatting. This is wild guys. I mean with my testing currently.
Back on mac (stable) now,…
Back on mac (stable) now, there are known obvious problem with proper battery/power management which I was expecting, like I plugged my mac for 2-3 hours and it was stuck at 62% in asahi and when I just rebooted on mac it's at 90%. Today it didn't even get hot at all, and I learned how to navigate in the new gnome, their shortcuts list is very helpful.
I will keep testing this thing, now it's... did I say it's very interesting? :)
Also when you install this with gnome, I don't know what happen but I was stuck on the timezone selection dialog, Orca didn't see anything other than the edit field to type a city and the previous button, I had to do random things with my trackpad and be lucky enough to get the next button after that.
Did I say tables in Writer, just because of the lack of nested hierarchy, are almost a fun experience? Caps lock + f give so much richer information than even nvda on windows, both in writer and even on the web.
Of course I haven't done anything production/serious on it yet, but I really wasn't expecting that much usability. Last time I had a good time with linux accessibility was in 2018 where x11 was still around, I mean more than today.
And orca is much much faster than VoiceOver on mac has ever been, closer t o speakup in tty mode which I am really surprised about. Beating NVDA on most average windows config (the key word here is average).
And personally I do love espeak but will definitely buy from voxyn soon.
I didn't even know that orca let us choose to use the screen reader cursor thing on the web like it's common on windows or let the app manage it, so f7 in firefox for example, and there the focus even follows, which isn't the case on mac and in chrome this could solve so many problems at once.
Do we still have to enable…
Do we still have to enable accessibility flag for chromium and other apps now?
no I don't think so.
I reinstalled Gnome and I didn' have to enable accessibility for Brave browser, or Firefox. I am not sure if thereÅ› reasons to worry about this these days yet.
What other shells than gnome are accessible and support wayland?
Is it just KDE? I just wish the shell and the super menu was accessible in gnome.
What no I used gnome shell…
What no I used gnome shell and super menu and it works.
It works but it's not really accessible.
I have found that if you bring up super menu and press windows D it will bring you to a dock thing. The accessibility in general could be improved.
Maybe we're not talking…
Maybe we're not talking about the same thing but I find gnome quite accessible and usable. It's not different than weird ui bugs with voiceover on mac. And gnome terminal is accessible too, with the things I've tried so far.
GNOME & The Super Key
The Super Key (Windows Key) search area could be better, but it works.
Super+A to show all applications may be an easier route to go about things.
Yep that's exactly what I do.
Yep that's exactly what I do.
Are you trying this on a vm?
Are you trying this on a vm? Or natively running it on the mac i.e, dual partician?
I am running this native.
The performance is so nice.
Native, you didn't read…
Native, you didn't read asahi linux?
Yes it kills most ultra optimized windows I've seen in term of performance. Aside even vo even the m4 mac I recently tried is slower than this thing.
OMG guys google docs works so well! :) general navigation and formatting announcement, no weird delays like with voiceover on the mac, tried this on chromium cause chrome has problem with arm linux or something like that... or just asahi specifically I think it's there under broken software.
I've noticed though that it doesn't seem possible to select regular text with shift arrows with orca on chromium? But I just tried this 2 minutes.
I know from the gnome article that this was a problem back in 2024, but is it possible to still get to the scrollbar in gnome terminal and manually go back like we do on windows when using flat layout to read output? I discovered it's ctrl shift v to paste, how do we select? I haven't fully read orca guide yet.
Just to clarify guys, we're…
Just to clarify guys, we're not saying it's ready to be used in production yet. There are weird behaviours/bugs here and there, but imo it's getting close to that very soon and probably already is if you're ready to debug yourself in some areas. Like I don't miss chrome os flex at all now that pure, modern and up to date linux seems to become an option again. There are weird things I avoid by muscle memory of someone who's already dealt with linux desktop accessibility in the past that I haven't covered here yet. But compared to the completely unusable mess it was with kde last year (and I mean it) I see myself switching to it for some key task while in college, google docs hopefully being a good example, and when possible coding.
As far as I know we can't yet attempt to get mathcat with orca though it's in the plan, for example.
I haven’t tried this yet
I tried linux mint and elementary OS in a VM and will try this one out
I was gonna try dool booting linux mint and windows but booting from the USB i got nothing even though i created it correctly
Wait, so can you boot natively windows and linux on arm mac?
Wait, so can you natively run windows and linux on arm macs? Or it’s just Linux? Haven't tried linux at all but, willing to give it a shot once this gets more stable, is there a guide on how to use it and set it up?
Linux only and from what I…
Linux only and from what I understand I'll test this out but I'm pretty sure virtualizing windows in asahi could be a better experience than from mac.
Keep us posted!
I'd love to know the differences. I'd like to be able to play audiogames like crazy party on that thing.
wine for mac discontinued, might run on arm linux. Proton better
Wine is sadly no longer a thing on Mac, but it’s still alive and kicking on linux. If proton works on ARM. that would be even better.
I’m assuming here that wine works on arm.
Thank you @Devin Prater
Dear open source, seriously? Just when I was about to get the perfect workflow just right.
Thanks for posting this so at least one other random user can find it.
I wasn't following the mailing list recently, but now I seriously wonder if I should even bother learning emacs even on mac? (edit, it's definitely useful so I'll continue, plus this is yet another potential opportunity for me in the future)
https://tweesecake.social/@pixelate/114419161975418355
Anyways.
A bit of positivism! :)
So 1password works great on linux, I didn't know that we can just use our session password as a method instead of the good old password (as touchid won't obviously work, you see?)
Terminal tip
In the gnome shell prefferences, accessed with orca object navigation mode, enable always use scrollbar and you can use shift page up/down and then the usual flat review commands to read previous screen content.
Note that like voiceover but way less worst orca will sometime read from before the latest output, nothing a clear screan with ctrl l won't solve.
Now I just have to find how to select output from that flat review and it will just be awesome.
The other libreoffice apps and more notes
Calc is somewhat usable. We can't scroll in the suggested formula list, but orca announces cell coordinates and even when the cell shows a formula result.
Impress is the worst, we seem to be able to navigate with tab and shift tab within a slide object but we don't hear anything when navigating by slides.
I wasn't expecting anything so this is already great, with writer seeming to be the priority and actually being quite good.
I have connected one of my google account with gnome and now the drive sync works seamlessly (haven't tried the other services), something macos and windows really should take notes IMO.
VLC seems to works quite well.
For the productivity, I am amazed by google docs, just light editing, closer to chromevox, will definitely use asahi instead of mac during team work especially with the fine live region control orca seems to provide, so if you have any m1 or m2 (not greater) macs, the potential accessibility landscape is finally getting really interesting.
The document viewer, if this is the only options for pdf, forget it :) but again I wasn't expecting anything. Will test with firefox if it can render table even there, chromium has a problem with this, as well as formatting for the screen reader being flat across all platforms.
The battery indicator is broken it doesn't refresh live, but it will tell you when the real battery level is around 6% still so that's good, plus with system reboots it gets the latest percentage. I knew this was a known issue beforehand, so 0 problem for me personally.
We have sounds when we plug in something, whether it's the charging cable (sb c) or a hard drive, thank you gnome for that.
This, aside the documented issue on github about orca unable to get the accessibility information after reload, is even more stable than the most stable vinux 4 distro I've ever tried in the past, love it.
Now I am trying to get fenrir work.