BrailleNote Touch Plus versus Braille Sense Polaris, which is better for an iPhone user?

By Skye, 11 May, 2020

Forum
Braille on Apple Products

Hi, all. I am a completely blind iPhone user for about 8 years now, and I love it! I am about to graduate high school in about a month and as a result have to give my BrailleNote Apex and other loaned products back to my school district, so I will be without a notetaker. I use a notetaker almost every day in conjuction with my iPhone, so I want to find the best one for me, as an Apex really doesn't do much. I can do a lot on my iPhone, but I still use the Apex for word processing, emailing, and file management. I would also just really like a better and more versitile product to broaden my capabilities as a blind member of society. I found articles on the BrailleNote Touch Plus and the Braille Sense Polaris, but after reading them and doing further research I simply cannot decide which would be best for me and which is the best product overall. In addition, I have never used any sort of Android product before and am concerned on how that will differ to the smooth, easy-to-use, and reliable accessibility of my iPhone. I'd love to hear overall thoughts and recommendations from people who have used either or both a Polaris and a Touch Plus to help me decide which I should try to get.
Thank you,
Bex

Options

Comments

By Chris Hill on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

Check the support policies and capabilities of both companies very carefully, it doesn't matter which product works better if one can be fixed and one can't.

By Jim D on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

Hello:
I think you will get a lot of differing opinions on this as many people prefer one product over another. I've used both of these products and, while they are both good products, I personally prefer the BrailleSense Polaris. It is much lighter and more portable. The BrailleNote Touch has a large touch screen, which is great, but it makes the product weigh a lot and is rather fragile. I also believe the commands are a bit more intuitive on the BrailleSense. I have used the Polaris as a display with an iOS device and it works as expected.
Hope this is helpful, good luck with your decision making process.

By Dustin on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

Since they're both Android there's a lot of similarities. One thing I've experienced and heard that is currently better on the Polaris is handling math in documents. Although, both can, the Polaris is easier and handles larger equations. Additionally, Google Drive integration within the File Manager has been getting better on the Polaris.
Hims support has been tricky as of late where I hear HumanWares has gotten better.

By Unregistered User (not verified) on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

In reply to by Dustin

When I spoke to company reps, the HIMS rep told me the Braillesense wasn't suitable for high-level maths. Google Drive and Desmos integration are pretty cool though, so I imagine it's fine as long as you don't need to do like Calculus or something.

Personally, I have a lot more faith in Humanware's product support. In the past, I've struggled to get help from HIMS in a timely manner.

By Ishkabibble on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

I have used both of the notetakers you have mentioned. I have used HumanWare’s products for quite a while now, (I started on the Apex, then upgraded to the Touch and am currently using the Touch Plus). I find that the commands and operating system structure vary widely between the HIMS and HumanWare notetakers. If you use an Apex currently I think the Touch Plus would be a better option, as the commands and the various menus are the same. Additionally, the Touch Plus has a newer version of Android which means better long-term app support. Since both of these devices are Android-based, you can run Google apps on them as well as whatever apps are available on the Play Store, so long as they are accessible in nature. I have Twitter, Spotify, Google Classroom and various other apps from the Play Store on my Touch Plus and they work perfectly. The Touch Plus also has a USB C charging port which is the standard for most electronic devices these days and the speakers are much better than those of the Polaris. Hope this helps. :)

By Skye on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

Hi again, Thank you all for your feedback. I'm still deciding, but it's great to hear everyone's oppinions and what they like or don't like about one or the other. Also, just know that this forum will always be open to discussion.

By Samtastic on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

There is an issue where the Touch Plus gets disconnected from VoiceOver and you have to re-pair it. I don't know if this is an issue with VoiceOver or the Touch or if the Polaris experiences the same issues. You may want to join the Facebook groups and email lists for the BrailleNote and Braille Sense and ask other users. If you don't want to deal with the connectivity issues you could consider a separate display for your iPhone such as the Brailliant 14 or the Focus 14.

By Skye on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

In reply to by Samtastic

Hi, I'm probably not going to use it as a braille display as I prefer braille screen input, but thanks for letting me know!

By Ishkabibble on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

There used to be issues with Bluetooth lag and typing on Braille displays but they have been resolved. I find it easier to type on my Braille display in a pinch, as I don’t actually need to touch my iDevice’s screen to enter text. As for keyboards, the Focus Braille displays and the keyboard of the BrailleSense Polaris are much squishier than that of the Apex and Touch Plus (meaning they are not as clicky and quieter). If you are worried about noise levels when typing, the Focus and Polaris keyboards are not that loud, but they are harder to type with (longer key travel). You can also use the Touch’s touchscreen to enter commands even when connected to an iDevice which would be a convenient solution to typing quietly.

By musicjunky on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

In reply to by Samtastic

I've never used one of these newer devices, but I also have pairing issues between my iPhone 8 and the old Braille Sense Plus. Sometimes the phone won't connect to it. So my guess is, this is nothing new.

By Skye on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

Hello again all,
Thank you everyone for all your kind words and feedback. After much consideration of both devices, I have decided to go with the Polaris. Despite me deciding, however, I am always open to more thoughts on this topic, and like I said before, this forum will always be open for discussion!
Thank you all so much!
Bex

By Skye on Thursday, May 21, 2020 - 20:26

Hi again all,
Has anyone had experience with the Department of Rehab? If so, does anyone know how long it takes to get a device from them once the tech report has been sent?
Thanks,
Bex

By Ahmed on Wednesday, September 21, 2022 - 20:26

Hello As a user of HimsInC braille products for all my education years starting from highschool and now using one for college I can safely say that for my use case when conected to VoiceOver on my Mac and Iphone and bluetooth to NVDA on my windows partition it does what I need it to do.
A note to some users I'm talking about the 2018 model of the braille sense polaris.
I only was able to try the brailleNoteTouch Plus because before SSb which is the agency that provides citizens with disabilities living in the state of Minnisota with services.
With the brailleSense Polaris I use if I compared it to the brailleNote Touch Plus for me once I felt the brailleNote Touch plus I thought to myself this braille display is very fragile.
Both braille displays run on the android mobile operating systems when compared to the previous generations of notetakers manufactured by Hims.
I use my BrailleSense Polaris as a refreshable braille display sometimes other times I like using it as a standalone notetaker.
In fact I'm about to post this using my braillesense.
one feature that is similar is the fact that both of these devices do offer their users direct access to both brailleSense specific applications as well as mainstream android apps.
if I was in your position I would go with the polaris.
But I honestly I can only give you recommendations I can't help you decide.